Managing IP Risk in Acquisitions

About the Author

Omeed Tabiei is the Managing Partner of Optimist Legal and an attorney licensed in California. A two-time software founder and an early in-house lawyer at Hyperloop One, he advises SaaS and startup founders from incorporation through fundraising and exit, and hosts the SaaS Buyers Club podcast.

Anyone who has done a lot of M&A deals has likely experienced the projections of the business not aligning with the original belief in the company’s potential. Here are some areas where your lawyer can help you make sure your projections align with reality.

1Ask All the Questions You Think You Shouldn’t Ask

Sellers sell for different reasons, often due to a decline in the business or in their interest in the business. Buyers are purchasing the business because they believe they can grow it and profit from it. So it’s important to understand where the business is placed in the market.

For example, if the business is intellectual property based, ask where competitors’ IP stands in relation to the target’s IP. The seller may see that competitors are closing in quickly and want out, and would likely only reveal this information if directly asked. Ask during due diligence, and ask early.

If you miss your forecast, that’s your #1 loss, so get as much information as possible from the seller; your lawyers will support you during due diligence in that regard. Because document requests are one of the most important parts of due diligence, where risk is assessed, lawyers can request documents pertaining to an identified risk and then craft representations and warranties that address it.

Asking the hard questions will uncover the items your lawyers need to draft representations and warranties addressing the risk.

2Diligence Potential Employee Legal Risks

What M&A and transactional lawyers often see is that many business owners have no controls or protection whatsoever within the business. Legal is often overlooked by entrepreneurs, and especially if the business is suffering, legal tends to be treated as unnecessary spend.

So it’s important to diligence separation and claims issues within the business you’re looking to acquire. What is the past history with partners? Look into the past history of the business. Any time there’s a separation, there needs to be a release agreement and payment. Yes, representations and warranties may cover this, but if to the seller’s knowledge there weren’t any potential claims or litigation, you don’t want to wait until there’s a lawsuit to address it.

3Diligence Potential IP Risks

For SaaS businesses, intellectual property leakage is often a concern. From the date of the term sheet, there needs to be a policy that no IP leaves the company. That means nobody is downloading anything, and if there’s an IT department, it needs to work with the attorneys to confirm, by checking the company’s electronic transaction history records, that nothing is being downloaded to USB sticks. This is a data security best practice. For buyers, if it’s found that things have been downloaded, it’s an opportunity to negotiate a discount to the purchase price.

4Incentivize Staff Loyalty

It’s important to incentivize staff loyalty during the sale or purchase of a business. One way to do this is to adopt an equity incentive plan if there’s not one in place, or to make sure there are milestones in employment agreements that incentivize people to stay, which helps prevent IP leakage. You want people to stay. A lot of people think the sale of a business means they’re going to be let go, so they quit, and those people often go to work for your top competitors.

If you’re an Amazon brand, for example, and have staff who have helped you hone in on your customer data and maximize profits, those staff members can easily go and replicate your company because they have all the data to do so.

5Get Detailed Information on Employee Performance

When you’re acquiring a company, you’re going to want to understand the history of its salespeople. It’s often said that 20% of the producers produce 80% of the results, so your best bet is finding out who those 20% are. This is the level of due diligence you’ll want to do before acquiring a company: analyze each employee’s history from a financial perspective, not just net sales.

6Pension Plans Can Carry the Biggest Risk for Acquirers

One of the biggest places to find gains is restructuring pension plans by changing from defined benefit plans to defined contribution plans for companies with 15 to 25 employees. This requires lawyers to look through all the pension plan documents. Pension plan risk is often assessed by accounting, but those numbers tend to be off because they’re assumptions. The lawyers review the plans and provide the exact details accounting needs to assess how much risk the pension plans pose. Especially with older companies, there’s a lot of risk of non-payment of the pension plans.

There was a big story in the news: Lord Green bought one of the biggest grocery chains in the UK, axed the pension plan to zero, and resold the company. He ended up having to pay over £300 million in settlements as a result of slashing the pension plan after acquiring the chain.

7Trademarks: Don’t Overlook This

If you’re purchasing a business and plan to continue operating it, trademarks are an important piece of the acquisition because they represent ownership of the brand name and related assets. Trademark due diligence tells you the status of brand ownership. If you acquire a company that doesn’t own its trademark, and someone else who does own it sues you after the acquisition, that could have been avoided simply by diligencing the trademark ownership status.

I continue this list in Managing IP Risk in Acquisitions: Further Considerations.

Buying a company with valuable IP?
Let’s map the IP risks and build the protections into your purchase agreement.

Attorney advertising. The content here is educational and does not substitute for tailored legal counsel.

Viewing this site or emailing the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past outcomes do not guarantee or predict a similar result in any future matter. Laws change and vary by jurisdiction, so consult a qualified attorney about your specific situation.